How Good is Vacheron Constantin’s Entry-Level FiftySix?

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix Self-Winding gold

With 263 years (and counting) of watchmaking history to draw from, Vacheron Constantin needed to reach back only a little more than half a century to find the inspiration for its latest all-new timepiece family, unveiled today at SIHH 2018 in Geneva. The Vacheron Constantin FiftySix collection takes as its template a vintage model from 1956, the now-iconic Reference 6073, giving it an elegantly modern twist and offering three distinctive models.

One of the most talked about watches at SIHH 2018 was the Vacheron Constantin FiftySix, by virtue of its price, which starts at just US$11,700. That’s half the price of the Overseas automatic sports watch, and a third less than the Quai de l’Île in steel. Is the watch any good?

Visually the FiftySix appears to be a departure from Vacheron Constantin’s house style, and takes a moment to get used to. But the design works.

Three by FiftySix

Three models are available (with more slated to be added later in the year), with the basic being the FiftySix Self-Winding. Having no complications, it is the thinnest of the lot, being slimmer than it looks, and cuts an elegant profile on the wrist.

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix Self-Winding gold

Visually, however, the FiftySix Complete Calendar is the most appealing, having the traditional triple calendar layout. It’s legible and obviously modern, yet vaguely retro thanks to the triple calendar complication.

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix complete calendar gold

Among these elements are the box-type crystals that rise well above the bezel, made of modern, scratch-resistant sapphire in the new models, as opposed to the plexiglas and mineral glass used in the vintage pieces; the use of self-winding movements in all the FiftySix models, including one entirely new in-house caliber, honoring the Ref. 6073 as one of the first Vacheron watches to be equipped with this type of movement; and the sector-type dials, with alternating Arabic numerals and baton hour markers in their chapter rings, enhanced with two separate, subtle tones to their finishing.

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix complete calendar steel 1

The FiftySix Day-Date is arguably the most practical, featuring the complications most useful in everyday life. But it is not as visually interesting as either of its siblings, and the displays cutting through the minute track are jarring.

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix day-date gold

Shared outsides…

According to Christian Selmoni, Vacheron Constantin’s Style & Heritage Director, the FiftySix was intended to be a “modern collection… a little bit based on [the ref. 6073 of 1956]”. It succeeds at that; while the FiftySix case shares the same distinctive lugs of the ref. 6073, it still looks and feels like a freshly conceived modern watch.

Though the case is just 40mm in diameter (all three versions are the same width), its footprint feels larger on the wrist, making it a good size for modern tastes.

Christian Selmoni, Style & Heritage Director and one of the longest tenured employees at Vacheron Constantin

Both the steel and gold versions of the FiftySix have the same case finish, which is mirror-polished on all surfaces. While the polishing is well done, it lacks visual variation, and the mirrored surface tends to pick up fingerprints.

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix Self-Winding gold dial

Overall though the case looks and feels good, aided by details like the “box-shape” sapphire crystal. It feels like a proper Vacheron Constantin case, and not an entry-level one.

The same can be said of the dials, which have three primary finishes: concentric stamped guilloche on the outermost track, radial brushing on the chapter ring for the hour markers and a grained surface in the centre. That’s matched with applied hour markers – which are solid gold – as well as neat printing.

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix complete calendar steel

The FIFTYSIX collection models itself off the Swiss watchmaker’s reference 6073 with a host of design elements that pay homage to the original timepiece. Most importantly though, Vacheron Constantin are making these new pieces more accessible to the everyday wearer with its retro-contemporary style that evokes both elegance and masculinity.

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix complete calendar steel 2

Ticking differently inside

All three models are indistinguishable on the outside, in terms of fit and finish. Inside, however, the watches diverge from each other.

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix movement comparison

The higher end FiftySix Complete Calendar and Day-Date are both powered by in-house movements that are different calibres (cal. 2475 SC/2 in the Day-Date and cal. 2460 QCL/1 in the Complete Calendar) but built on the same base cal. 2460. Now well over a decade old, the cal. 2460 in found in some of Vacheron Constantin’s priciest watches.

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix day-date steel

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix cal. 2475-1

It’s a sophisticated and fairly complex movement, made up of 182 parts in its simplest, time-only variant, about a quarter more than a lower cost movement. Even the stop seconds function (which relies on a lever to touch the balance wheel), is made up of well-finished several levers.

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix cal. 2475

The cal. 2460 is bears the Poincon de Geneve, or Geneva Seal hallmark, which means its decorative finishing is up to scratch. Even the levers for the hack seconds are straight grained on top and bevelled on their edges, as are the teeth of the barrel wheels.

In short, the movements in both the FiftySix Complete Calendar and Day-Date are very, very well executed.

The base model in the collection, the FiftySix Self-Winding, uses a “manufacture”, rather than in-house, movement. Named the cal. 1326, it is based on the Cartier 1904 MC that was introduced in 2012 as Cartier was rapidly building up its watch manufacturing prowess.

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix Self-Winding steel

Designed by a team led by Carole Forestier, then head of development at Cartier but now in the same role at parent company Richemont’s consolidated movement department, the 1904 MC is a solid, workhorse movement designed to be a upmarket replacement for the ETA 2892. Robustly built and found in watches like the Tank MC, the movement has double barrels as well as an efficient “Magic Rotor” winding mechanism.

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix cal. 1326-4

But the movement was significantly dressed up for its Vacheron Constantin duty as the cal. 1326, most obviously with a 22k red gold rotor bearing an open-worked Maltese cross. Notably, the edges of the Maltese cross are bevelled by hand, and form one of the most labour intensive and expensive operations of the movement production.

At the same time, the bridges were also reshaped to give them more curved and elegant shapes. The result is a properly upscale looking movement.

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix cal. 1326-3

The components for the cal. 1326 are produced by ValFleurier, the secretive movement manufacturer owned by Richemont that produces parts and whole movements for many of the group’s brands. Assembly and finishing is then done by Vacheron Constantin, which means the movement is significantly more attractive than any other version of the same calibre. Both the Cartier and Piaget (found inside the Polo S) versions of the movement are less elaborately decorated.

While the movement is as attractively finished as with other watches in the price segment, it is necessarily not decorated to the same degree as the in-house calibres. The differences are mostly minor, like the tumble polishing of the pallet fork bridge and wheels for instance. The anglage on the bridge is done via CNC machining, and not polished subsequently, leaving faint machining marks.

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix cal. 1326-2

Vacheron Constantin Fiftysix cal. 1326

That being said, the FiftySix Self-Winding as a whole is well executed for what it costs. Whether or not an affordably put together watch like this furthers Vacheron Constantin’s brand equity is a question that is important but impossible to answer before some time has passed.

Price and availability

Available at Vacheron Constantin boutiques and retailers in September 2018, the FiftySix is priced as follows in US and Singapore dollars.

FiftySix Self-Winding steel (ref. 4600E/000A-B442) – US$11,700 or S$17,100

FiftySix Self-Winding 18k rose gold (ref. 4600E/000R-B441) – US$19,400 or S$28,400

FiftySix Complete Calendar steel (ref. 4000E/000A-B439) – US$21,600 or S$31,700

FiftySix Complete Calendar 18k rose gold (ref. 4000E/000R-B438) – US$35,800 or S$52,400

FiftySix Day-Date steel (ref. 4400E/000A-B437) – US$17,400 or S$25,400

FiftySix Day-Date 18k rose gold (ref. 4400E/000R-B436) – US$32,500 or S$47,500